An Argument in Favour of Civil Disobedience – Steve Loo

8 Nov

I have been involved in the Occupy Calgary movement from its inception. I have 2 jobs. I’m university educated – in fact Mayor Nenshi was one of my professors at Mount Royal University. 

I joined the Occupy movement because I believe democracy is eroding in Canada. 

More than ever, we live in society where large corporations influence government policy. A prime example is the reversal of the oil royalties in Alberta. The auditor general Fred Dunn was chastised by the government for reviewing and suggesting that the oil and gas royalty taxes be raised. There was an outcry largely led by the oil and gas industry, and province backed down from their plans to raise royalties. As a province, we lost an excellent opportunity for badly needed revenue to fund the social, health and infrastructure needs.  Another example is the lack of regulation – no oil sands extraction project has been rejected by the Energy Resources Conservation Board despite conflicting environmental assessments and costs to community. Now, communities downstream from oil sands projects are adversely affected because of the waste that is produced and flow into the rivers. Dr. John O’Connor raised the alarm on the health concerns – specifically alarming rates of bile duct cancer. The province made allegations of malpractice for causing undue alarm when really they were, and continue to be, in denial.  

In the Occupy Calgary meetings, we make our decisions using the consensus process. Everyone involved in the movement has an equal say regardless of income or age. It is a difficult process that requires patience and learning new ways of communicating. In the end, this is a better way of organizing because of the inclusivity. 

We must remember that the foundations of our culture was laid through protest and civil disobedience. In the Bible, the Book of Matthew tells about Jesus driving the moneychangers out of the marketplace because he saw greed within the temple walls. Gandhi defied the salt laws imposed by the British by marching to the beaches and making salt out of seawater. Rosa Parks defied segregation by refusing to move out of the front half of the bus where only white people sat. Martin Luther King Jr got arrested several times and won a Nobel Peace Prize because of his opposition to segregation, violence, poverty and the war in Vietnam. Nelson Mandela was labelled a terrorist and imprisoned for close to 30 years for his opposition to apartheid.  Democracy is not just voting at election time – it’s about the ability to express dissent and work to change the status quo. Dictators in South America and Eastern Europe and most recently the Middle East have fallen with citizens rising up and peacefully affirming their rights to a dignified life. Similar to those who participated in social movements discussed here, the people of Occupy Calgary have peacefully come together at Olympic Plaza to name injustice and organize for a better world. And like them, we will overcome opposition, whether it comes from businesses, governments, police, and military (what we call the 1%), every step of the way.

I thank the indigenous people for hosting us on their land. I thank the Mayor Nenshi, City of Calgary, and Calgary Police for respecting our right and determination to protest, to organize and work towards a better more inclusive world. 

In closing, I leave with you a quote from Gandhi:
“First they ignore you. Then they laugh at you. Then they fight you. Then you win.”


2 Responses to “An Argument in Favour of Civil Disobedience – Steve Loo”

  1. Steve Loo November 21, 2011 at 6:24 pm #

    Alessandro, I would like to thank you for reading article and also taking the time to write a response.

    I find it interesting that you talk about the ” economic attempt to create fairness in commerce through the constitution”. I think it is important to remember and recognize that much of that push was brought about by pressure from poverty activists and labor unions advocating on issues such as stronger practices to ensure safe working conditions, staff paid fairly and working decent hours, etc. Within that pressure and advocacy, they utilized petitions, right to strike and even setting up a camp site and 24 hour protest to blockade the worksite. In the example of slavery within the US and Britain, there were decades of campaigns to abolish slavery. (I don’t know much about indentured servitude so I won’t go there)
    I like your idea of “prevent perpetual indebtrfness”. The reality is that there are multiple approaches and more importantly we need to work together in order to achieve that goal of creating a better world for everyone.

  2. Alessandro Machi November 8, 2011 at 5:54 pm #

    Your quote…”We must remember that the foundations of our culture was laid through protest and civil disobedience.” endquote.

    I would say yes and no to that.

    Another foundation was an economic attempt to create fairness in commerce through the constitution. However, I consider the constitution a fail as slavery did not have a sunshine clause whereas the indentured serfs from England could eventually work off their debt. (although there were tricks used to extend a serfs time as an indentured serf).

    I would suggest that fighting for more tools to prevent perpetual indebtrfness to the banks would be something worth fighting for. To that end, Changing the banking law that “debt restructuring first requires a default” be changed to “debt restructuring does not first require a default” would dramatically lift the 99% on par with the banks in negotiating how their existing debt will be paid back.


Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: